The 2005 Utica, NY Police Killing of Walter Washington

by Brendan Maslauskas Dunn

This article was first published in November of 2005 by the Utica Tangerine – the only local publication willing to publish this story, and later by multiple Indymedia websites across the US. Love and Rage is republishing this to shed light on the Utica police murder of Walter Washington that occurred 15 years ago today – July 5th. This republished article is the first in a series of articles that will shed light on the Utica police killings of Walter Washington and Jessie Lee Rose and the push for justice being led by the families of those whose lives were tragically cut short. We hope that you join us at Love and Rage as we stand with both families and the growing numbers of supporters to find justice for both Walter Washington and Jessie Lee Rose! Say their names and join the movement for a world free of police and State violence. Black Lives Matter! Native Lives Matter!

washington
Walter Lee Washington who was tragically killed by Samuel Geddes of the Utica Police Department.

On the evening of July 5, 2005 Walter Washington headed over to his partner Patricia’s house. Patricia and Walter had been a couple for 20 years and parented three children together. The two had recently been dealing with turmoil in their relationship. 

Though he had a key to the house, he decided to sit on the porch to have Patricia come out to talk. Patricia called the police, complaining that an unwanted person would not leave her residence.

Right when the police arrived, Walter Washington exited the premises. The police conducted a search and finding no one, left the residence.

After they left, Washington went back to his partner’s porch and waited there for her to come out. Patricia called the police again at around 11:50 with the same complaint. The same patrol car responded to the call and arrived at the house, pulled up to the driveway and parked next to the porch where Mr. Washington was sitting. He ran down the steps, went down a sidewalk which ran along the house to the back, and proceeded to follow that sidewalk, taking a sharp right around the back of the house.

At this time, Utica police officer Samuel Geddes followed him, while a NY State Trooper who was in the car with him, Officer Haver, went around the front of the house to meet Geddes in the back.

Patricia and her children were in the house at this time. They did not hear any noise from either the police or Washington outside until two rapid gunshots rang out. Patricia and the kids ran out of the house and down the path which Washington had taken earlier. Washington’s son looked around the corner of the house and saw Officer Geddes under some trees, getting up from a kneeling position, his gun aimed where Mr. Washington presumably was. Geddes yelled at Patricia and the children to get back inside the house.

Patricia is still in a state of disbelief and grief over the matter. On looking back at the tragedy she said she did not feel threatened but wanted her boyfriend to leave because it was late at night. “If I had known [the police] were going to shoot Walter, I would never have called them.”

By the time the EMTs arrived it was already too late. When they arrived Mr. Washington had a faint heartbeat, but the bullet’s path through his aorta and lungs made it impossible to save him.

Patricia and her children were whisked away to the police station to be questioned. Washington’s brothers and parents were notified about what had happened, but were not allowed into the hospital to see him for quite some time.

Officer Geddes was placed on administrative leave for a week, with pay. The District Attorney’s office, claiming that they would leave “no stone unturned” in their investigation, concluded in one week’s time that the actions of Geddes “were a reasonable and justifiable use of deadly physical force.” Geddes was put back on the job. Within a week some city residents complained about Geddes’ belligerent behavior towards Black youth in Utica. In the past Geddes had been accused of racial profiling.

Patricia noted that throughout that entire week, no one from the DA’s office came to her house until the day before the final DA report came out. District Attorney Michael Arcuri made conclusions in this investigation without a trajectory report, looking at the autopsy report or at the NY State Police report on the actions of State Trooper Haver (which to this date has not been concluded and is still under investigation).

The report also mentions that after Washington was shot and had slumped to the ground, gloves were found on the scene, as well as a pellet gun and a pocket knife which were both on the ground. Although it was not mentioned in the report, the DA made later statements that the gloves were on Walter’s hands that night.

Arcuri and the Utica Police Department ran with several different stories of how events unfolded that night. In public statements and reports, they made several changes in the position of Geddes and Haver and the actions and position of Washington. The police even ran with a story that tried to place the blame of the shooting on an unidentified man whose physical appearance was vague enough to match many Black men in the neighborhood.

The story they eventually chose to run with was that Washington had a gun and aimed it at Geddes. It turned out that, according to the police, the weapon was a pellet gun.

It was immediately following the shooting of Washington that Geddes saw that there was a witness to the shooting and asked her if she had seen a man with a black hooded sweatshirt run away. This story was aired on WKTV’s morning news broadcast, but was soon abandoned after the police realized that bullets from Geddes’ gun were lodged in Mr. Washington’s body and the house where the shooting took place and this evidence would not be so easy to cover up.

blmutica3
“No justice! No peace!” A banner captures the sentiment felt by many Utica residents 15 years after the Utica police killing of Walter Washington. These protesters were gathered at the May 31 Black Lives Matter rally in Utica, NY. Photo credit: Brendan Maslauskas Dunn

According to Arcuri, the officers told Washington to stop running “several times,” to put his hands up and to put the gun down “several times.” Patricia, her four children and neighbors never heard any of this. They were all in perfect hearing distance.

The neighbor of Patricia, who shares the same building, was in a room directly above where Washington was shot. After she heard the gunshots, she looked outside to see Washington on the ground looking up in her direction. She confirmed that she did not see any gun either in Washington’s possession or in the area surrounding him. She also noticed that while this scene was unfolding, Trooper Haver was off to the side throwing up.

The autopsy report shows that Washington was shot in his left side – his left upper chest cavity to be exact. Which leads to the question: how was Mr. Washington shot in his left side if, according to the DA’s office, his front was facing the police as he was backing away from them, gun pointed, and he was right-handed?

The bullet that was used to kill Walter was of a hollow-tipped point black talon design.

The unique design of this bullet enables the tip to expand in size as it enters an object, or any mass. The tip spirals out and becomes larger the farther it travels through a mass. These bullets have been ironically called “cop-killers” because they can shred through materials such as Kevlar. The DA claimed that Geddes did in fact shoot to kill as he had taken careful aim at Washington’s “central mass” (where his heart, lungs and vital organs are located).

What is perhaps even more disturbing than the bullet used to kill Washington was the position of Washington’s body after he was shot.

According to Patricia and her son, the heels of Washington’s shoes could be seen sticking out of the side of the house where Washington fell. This means that his body was to the back of the house. He was lying on his right side. The witness who looked out the window above Washington and saw him confirmed this position as well.

But when the EMTs arrived they found Washington lying on his wound (his left side), with his back facing the house. This means that somehow between the time Washington was shot and the time of the EMTs’ arrival, Washington’s body was moved 180 degrees.

The EMTs also stated, contrary to the DA’s report and the police reports, that Washington’s pocket knife was not on the ground at all. It was in Washington’s pocket. The EMTs also noted that Washington indeed had gloves, but they were in his pocket as well when they arrived.

This also runs contrary to the DA’s story claiming Washington was wearing gloves that night. If the DA’s story is true then it would partially explain why there were no fingerprints whatsoever found on the pellet gun. Perhaps the gun came from elsewhere.

When questioned about the entire story Barrie Gewanter, Director of the Central NY Civil Liberties Union, stated that she was “disappointed that the DA released a report without questioning witnesses, neighbors, or the EMTs.” She also said, “Given no clear evidence on whether or not Walter [Washington] was wearing gloves, and the fact that there were no fingerprints on the pellet gun, this raises questions as to where the gun came from.”

106342038_2326092944360750_4050127125332930672_n
Samueal Geddes, who after killing Walter Washington was promoted to the rank of Sargent, is showing off an LRAD weapon which is used for crowd control during mass demonstrations. Photo credit: Observer Dispatch.

The next door neighbor claimed that after Mr. Washington was shot, Geddes ran over to his car to retrieve something from his trunk. He then brought that item to Washington’s body.

The scene in Utica began to change following Mr. Washington’s shooting as well.

State Trooper Haver was with Utica police officer Geddes in the first place because they were working at the time under Operation IMPACT (Integrated Municipal Police Anti-Crime Team). Operation IMPACT was first announced to the public by Governor Pataki in his State of the State Address in 2004. The purpose of the program is to combat blue collar crime, illegal drugs and guns. The program has developed in numerous cities throughout New York and it links local law enforcement with state and federal agencies.

This program abruptly ended in Utica nine days after Walter Washington was shot and killed.

Officer Geddes acted as star witness in a number of cases brought to court that involved Operation IMPACT. One can only imagine the difficulty Arcuri would encounter if his star witness was taken off the police force for unjustifiably shooting and killing someone.

Arcuri did note that the investigation would not go to a grand jury and would instead be undertaken solely by his office because it would spare Geddes from being rigorously investigated by a grand jury if he did in fact act properly.

Furthermore, Arcuri attempted to either silence or write off people in the community giving different accounts of the story.

One local activist, who wanted to remain anonymous for fear of retaliation, helped organize a community group called Justice For Walter was surprised to find the DA pull up in her driveway one day. He told her to “keep quiet” because his office would take care of the matter. He also added that it was an election year and did not want any disturbances.

She ignored the DA and pointed out that Arcuri’s “credibility has been shot since day one” because of past cases he was involved in where he withheld exculpatory evidence.

Arcuri also accused citizens of “playing the race card” whenever they brought up the fact that a white cop had killed a Black man.

The future is uncertain for the Washington family in their search for truth and justice. However, there is some hope. Lawyers have offered help as well as the ACLU. An employee at the Department of Justice was appalled that there was no federal investigation into the matter and that checks and balances have been non-existent. Mr. Washington’s parents filed a lawsuit against the city. Aside from creating the Justice For Walter group, some residents have talked about implementing a Cop Watch program to police the police.

Hopefully, the truth will be revealed and Walter Washington’s family will receive some justice. Perhaps the social justice groups forming in the area as a response to the killing of Mr. Washington will find some form of justice the Washington family so desperately needs.


This article was slightly edited for Love and Rage Media. Some names and last names have been omitted on the request of those interviewed. 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: